Chandler Macleod
September 13, 2018
What is the true cost of hiring the wrong person?


Hiring the wrong person doesn’t just affect your bottom line – it can also have indirect costs on your business. Team culture, productivity, and even client relationships can take a hit if you bring the wrong person into the team.


So just how much can a bad hire impact your business? And how can you ensure you find the right fit for a successful hire?


As a business owner or manager, you know that hiring the wrong person is the most costly mistake you can make.


Brian Tracy, motivational speaker and self-development author


Financial Costs


Recruiting and training expenses don’t come cheap. In fact, studies show the real cost of a new hire, in terms of time and money, can be more than 50% of a person’s salary. And a study from the Australian, quoted in Business Review Australia, revealed a bad hire can cost a business up to 2.5 times the salary of the employee.


The financial costs of hiring a bad (or unsuitable) egg can include:


  • Recruitment advertising fees
  • Staff time spent on recruitment processes
  • Salary payments (yes, even if your new employee isn’t a great fit, you still have to pay them for their time)
  • Education and training
  • Costs to rehire
  • Potential legal costs during termination.


A bad hire can cost a business up to 2.5 times the salary of the employee in question.


Workplace Info



Team Culture and Morale


Aside from the obvious financial costs that can come with a bad hire, hiring the wrong person for the job can also put your team’s morale at risk.


The National Business Research Institute report that 37% of companies who reported ‘bad hires’ claimed it negatively affected employee morale and over 18% claimed it had a negative impact on client relations.


If a new employee is underqualified (or simply not pulling their weight) and not adding value to the team, the other teammates often have to pick up the slack. This could lead to resentment of your team’s new colleague.


And if a new employee is simply not a good fit with the company’s existing culture, this can take away the harmony and lead to a tense, negative environment.


Decreased Productivity


Again, if your new hire isn’t quite as qualified as they implied on their CV, the rest of your team could be the ones who have to pay for it with extra effort. This negative impact on productivity could see your other staff working harder to meet KPIs, leading to burnout and loss of productivity.


The time spent rehiring for the position can also lead to other tasks going overdue.


39% of businesses report a decrease in productivity due to a bad hire.


The Costs of a Bad Hire, Global HR Research


Chandler Macleod Group offers psychometric testing to help you gain an understanding of your potential new employees’ behaviours, key motivations, limitations, and development opportunities. Rather than just hiring for skills alone, psychometric testing can help you find the best fit for your team.


Get in touch today to learn more about our staffing and recruitment services.

Liked this blog? Share it with your network:

A person in a suit handing a white envelope to someone across a wooden table.
By Chandler Macleod October 10, 2025
Learn how to respectfully resign from your job, what to expect during the resignation process, and how to find your next role.
Business meeting at a wooden table, papers, laptops, phones, and hands in action.
By Adam Rule September 4, 2025
Learn about the 6 key trends shaping the evolving Australian workforce in 2025 and how employers can respond to the challenges in recruitment and retention.
Large mining machine, orange and yellow, extracting material near a brown mountain, blue sky backdrop.
By Martyn Hill September 1, 2025
Discover how experienced mining professionals can stay relevant in the age of automation. Learn practical tips to adapt, upskill, and lead in modern mining operations.
Australian Parliament House with flag flying; blue sky, reflection in water.
By Sarah Borg August 4, 2025
Discover the top tips and recruiter insights on the application and recruitment process for Australian Public Service jobs.
A man is mopping the floor next to a yellow caution wet floor sign.
By Nadine Bayer July 22, 2025
Learn the practical steps to reduce risks and maintain a safe and healthy office environment.
A group of Barbie dolls are standing next to each other
By Louise Bennett July 2, 2025
Explore how Barbie’s cultural impact is empowering the next generation of women in leadership and reshaping workplace gender dynamics.
A group of people are sitting around a table looking at a piece of paper.
By Pierre Lintzer May 9, 2025
The hiring challenge facing HR managers and team leaders in local government is the competition for secure skilled, committed workers.
A construction worker is holding a hard hat in his hand.
By Karla Illingworth April 29, 2025
Chandler Macleod is the winner of the 2025 RCSA Industry Award for Excellence in Safety and Wellbeing Culture, celebrating 65 years of safety leadership, innovation, and a culture of shared responsibility across Australia and New Zealand.
Mining engineers and workers in safety gear discuss a project with heavy machinery operating in the background.
By Karla Illingworth February 13, 2025
Workplace safety is a shared responsibility. Learn how Chandler Macleod collaborates with employees and clients to build a safer work environment through communication, empowerment, and strong partnerships.
Safety Messaging
By Karla Illingworth February 13, 2025
Discover why safety messaging is a shared responsibility in the workplace. Learn how clear communication and proactive reporting create a safer environment for everyone.